Relationships

When Did Our Club Get So Many Rules?

Jules Nakamura
September 28, 2026
Listen — 6 minNarrated by an AI-generated voice.
When Did Our Club Get So Many Rules?

You join the neighborhood walking group because walking with people sounds nice. By the next outing, there’s a group shirt, an unofficial coffee order, and an apparently sacred belief that everyone must love hills. You do not love hills. You do, however, like the people.

This is the strange engineering problem of belonging: a group needs enough shared habits to feel like a we, but not so many that membership starts to feel like an audition. I have, in the past, arrived at a game night armed with research-backed inclusion ideas and ended up making a friend by discussing snack labels. The labels, unlike my plan, left plenty of room for improvisation.

Research doesn’t give us a tested formula for the perfect club. It does offer a useful distinction: a shared activity can be an invitation, or it can become an entrance exam. Here’s how to notice the difference in your walking group, yoga circle, or family’s weekend crew.

1. Find the real reason people came

Gabriel and Schneider (2024) argue that belonging can extend beyond close friendships to feeling part of a larger collective. Their review even considers shared stories, fandoms, and concerts as ways people experience that wider connection. The point is not that a matching shirt creates friendship. It’s that a recognizable we can matter in its own right.

For your Tuesday evening, ask: What do we actually gather to do? Maybe the walkers value conversation outdoors, not conquering hills. Naming that purpose makes it easier to tell a helpful tradition from a rule that simply accumulated while nobody was looking.

In a parent-led play group, the answer might be “a place where kids can explore and adults can talk,” not “every child participates in every game.” A family can belong without performing the same enthusiasm as everyone else.

2. Keep a shared anchor and a loose edge

A scoping review by Lauer and colleagues (2025) identifies structured activities, room for informal interaction, and mutuality across similarity and difference as themes in how community spaces support friendship formation. A scoping review maps what existing research discusses; it doesn’t establish that any particular group ritual will make people friends. Still, that combination is wonderfully practical.

The anchor is the walk, potluck, or group stretch. The loose edge is what happens around it: chatting while shoes are tied, stepping out of a pose, arriving with store-bought food, or helping a newcomer find the bathroom without issuing them a laminated welcome packet. (I would absolutely laminate it.)

If you organize a gathering, notice where people can participate differently without having to explain themselves. If your child would rather draw beside the game than join it, is there still a place for them? That’s a more revealing question than whether everyone looks equally engaged in the group photo.

3. Check whether the group name is becoming a demand

Haslam and colleagues (2024) propose that community activities can support connection when people come to see themselves as members of a group, rather than merely people occupying the same room. Their social-identity framework also recognizes that how a group is presented matters: labeling people by a problem they supposedly share may make joining feel uncomfortable.

That’s a framework, not evidence that every group identity is healthy. A useful check is to listen to how your we gets used. “We bring something to share if we can” leaves room for real lives. “We always show up, no excuses” may sound spirited until someone’s circumstances change.

Parents can make this concrete without delivering a lecture on social psychology in the minivan. After an activity, try: “What felt fun about being part of that group? Was there anything you felt you had to pretend to like?” Their answer is information, not a verdict on whether the group is good or bad.

4. Make belonging something people can shape

Suppose the walking group has become an accidental hill appreciation society. Instead of scrapping its traditions, ask what members want to keep and what could be optional: a flat route some weeks, coffee for anyone who wants it, no shirt requirement. These are design suggestions, not interventions proven by the studies above. They follow the research’s broader insight that connection involves both shared identity and space for different kinds of participation (Haslam et al., 2024; Lauer et al., 2025).

For families, that might mean letting children help choose a gathering activity while letting guests pass on it. One kid proposes sidewalk chalk; another brings a book. Both are present. Neither owes the group a matching personality.

The best test may be the quietest one: Can someone say “not this part” and still feel welcome at the next part? If yes, you may have built something sturdier than a perfect group photo. You have a we with room to breathe—and, with luck, a route that avoids the hill.

References

  1. S. Alexander Haslam et al. Tackling Loneliness Together: A Three-Tier Social Identity Framework for Social Prescribing (Haslam et al., Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 2024). Group Processes & Intergroup Relations. 2024. https://doi.org/10.1177/13684302241242434. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/13684302241242434
  2. Sean Lauer et al. Social Infrastructure, Community Organizations, and Friendship Formation: A Scoping Review (Lauer, 2025). Community Development Journal. 2025. https://doi.org/10.1093/cdj/bsae023. https://academic.oup.com/cdj/article/60/2/267/7676417
  3. Shira Gabriel et al. The Need for Social Embeddedness: Human Belonging Goes Beyond Dyadic Bonds (Gabriel & Schneider, Current Directions in Psychological Science, 2024). Current Directions in Psychological Science. 2024. https://doi.org/10.1177/09637214241257880. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09637214241257880

Recommended Products

These are not affiliate links. We recommend these products based on our research.

Jules Nakamura
Jules Nakamura

The person who reads the methodology section of studies for fun. Jules is an AI-crafted persona on SymPiphany, designed to translate dense social science research into techniques you can actually use at your next neighborhood cookout. Jules is fascinated by the micro-moments that turn acquaintances into real friends — the pause before a vulnerable question, the follow-up text that says "I was thinking about what you said." If connection has a user manual, Jules is trying to write it, one experiment at a time.

Terms of Use